
Yesterday the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences (aka the people who decide the Emmys) announced their top ten finalists in the category of Best Drama Series and Best Comedy Series. Here's the finalists in each caegory, as well as the episode for which they are being considered:
TOP 10 COMEDY SERIES FINALISTS
"Curb Your Enthusiasm" ("The Bat Mitzvah")
"Entourage" ("The Day F***ers")
"Family Guy" ("Padre de Famila")
"Flight of the Conchords" ("Sally Returns")
"The Office" (title to come)
"Pushing Daisies" ("Pie-lette")
"30 Rock" ("Cooter")
"Two and a Half Men" ("Rough Night in Hump Junction")
"Ugly Betty" ("Something Wicked This Way Comes")
"Weeds" ("Go").
TOP 10 DRAMA SERIES FINALISTS
"Boston Legal" ("The Court Supreme")
"Damages" (Pilot)
"Dexter" ("The Dark Defender")
"Friday Night Lights" ("Leave No One Behind")
"Grey’s Anatomy" ("Freedom, Parts 1 and 2")
"House" ("Frozen")
"Lost" ("The Constant")
"Mad Men" (Pilot, "Smoke Gets in Your Eyes")
"The Tudors" (#205)
"The Wire" (Series finale, "30")
So, which of these series will be making the final five in each category? The Acedemy won't be releasing the full list of official nominees until July 17th. However, we have our picks for the final five in each category here. read them after the jump!
Best Comedy
30 Rock
The Office
Pushing Daisies
Flight of the Conchords
Ugly Betty
First, let's start with the funny, and do Best Comedy Series. First off, there's three series that are shoo-ins right off the bat. Ugly Betty has come off a season thast developed the characters even more, and is widely considered to be even stronger than the first. Considering that many thought it would have been the big winner last year, it should still be in the final five this year. That said, last year's winner, 30 Rock, also is coming off a stronger season than the first, and even gained in the ratings a little. Nabbing nomination number two should be easier than winning a Page-off. The Office is the third series that shouldn't be sweating it out come July 17th. By finally bringing Jim and Pam together (and not screwing it up), the series has averted a potential Moonlighting curse. Plus, Steve Carell's got the buzz, and it should help The Office to another nomination.
As for the last two slots, it's a bit harder of a toss-up. While Two and a Half Men is TV's highest rated sitcom, that may count for little in this strike-shortened season where quality became the forerunner to quantity. Weeds had a fairly loopy third season, and will likely get lost in the fray once again (though look for it to score a few acting nods). While it's encouraging to see an animated series make the top ten, I have a feeling that Family Guy may have scathingly lampooned too many voters already to make the top five. Plus, there are too many people who would consider it blasphemy to have the first animated series to get a nomination NOT be The Simpsons. That brings us down to four, and for these last two slots, I'm betting on the fresh blood. Of the three HBO shows, while Flight of the Conchords has the lowest ratings, it garnered a nod from the Golden Globes, and is considered one of the freshest and most creative shows out there, so look for it to edge out Entourage and Curb Your Enthusiasm. That leaves the last slot to Pushing Daisies. While it's been off the radar for awhile, the fact that it made the top ten shows that it's still freshj in voter's minds, and the unique concept and stellar performances (Kristin Chenowith!!) should push it into the last slot.
Best Drama:
House
Lost
Grey's Anatomy
Mad Men
The Wire
Now it's time to get serious and take a gander at the Drama category, which this year is a tough one to wager on. The one series that should be considered a shoo-in in House, which refreshed its format this year with an influx of new characters that gave the series some fresh blood. Combine that with still-crackling stories and performances, and you have a series that fits the bill for best Drama. It'll have to fend off another series that gained momentous creative resurgence this year, ABC's Lost. The resurrection of the island serial this year has been hailed by critics and (rabid) fans alike, with many non-fans praising the show's ability to create fantastic drama, even if you have no idea what's going on. Lost's evening companion, Grey's Anatomy, should also score another nod, which is sure to cause a stir. While the show faltered early on, it recovered nicely in its last few episodes (which, coincidentally enough, are the ones voters will view), and it has the overall popularity (and ace acting) to bring itself to the table once again.
That once again leaves us with two slots, and plenty of series to duke it out for them. I have a feeling the courtroom dramas Boston Legal and Damages will cancel each other out in the series category, but look for both to score some acting nods. While Friday Night Lights is one of my favourite shows, it had a better chance with its stronger first season than it did with this one. While Dexter has a large cult fan base, many voters may consider it too dark for the big prize. Of the two period dramas, Mad Men won the big prize at the Golden Globes, and is overall more highly praised than The Tudors, so look for it to snag a slot. That leaves the last one to The Wire, which, even in its uneven final season, was still better than most dramas on TV, and sorely deserves to be recognized for six seasons of outstanding entertainment.
That's our picks. What do you think? And are there any shows that missed the cut that you wanted to see make it through to the final five? Continue reading "Emmy's 2008: Picking the Final Five"

